The Greatest Pool Players of All Time, Measured by Titles and by Action

Posted on: Last Updated: Views: 32
Editorial Team

Author:

Expertise: Online casino, iGaming

Pool keeps two sets of books on its champions, one for world titles and Hall of Fame plaques and one for what a player won and lost when the money was on the table. The argument over the greatest pool player of all time has always turned on which book counts for more. Snooker and three-cushion grew up around governing bodies, but pocket billiards in America and the Philippines grew up in rooms where a match was a wager first and a sporting event second, which is why the stories of Willie Mosconi, Minnesota Fats and Efren Reyes are gambling history and sports history at once.

A single match from 1996 shows both ledgers at work. That November, Reyes and Earl Strickland met in Hong Kong for a three-day race to 120 racks of nine-ball, winner-take-all, for $100,000, a purse bigger than the $60,000 Reyes collected three years later for the first televised world nine-ball championship. Reyes came back from 17 racks down to win 120 to 117. The best pool players of all time appear below in the order the Billiard Congress of America inducted them into its Hall of Fame, with the one current player not yet inducted at the end.

Ralph Greenleaf, the Vaudeville Champion

The Billiard Congress of America Hall of Fame credits Greenleaf with 14 world pocket billiard titles between 1919 and 1937 and made him one of its first three inductees in 1966. Among the legendary pool players of his era, none drew paying theater crowds the way he did, touring a vaudeville trick-shot act with his wife, the actress Amelia Ruth Parker. Alcohol undid much of it. In 1935 he vanished before a New York tournament and turned up in Oklahoma, arrested as a vagrant, and won his release by running 87 balls to prove who he was. Greenleaf set a pattern the sport would see again, a showman whose talent earned the crowd’s money and whose habits spent it.

Willie Mosconi, the Champion Who Played It Straight

Mosconi won the world straight pool title 15 times between 1941 and 1957, the count his 1993 obituaries used, entered the Hall of Fame in 1968, and always insisted he had played everyone straight. In February 1978, ABC’s Wide World of Sports staged a $15,000 match at the Waldorf Astoria between Mosconi and Rudolf Wanderone, the man calling himself Minnesota Fats, and about 11 million viewers watched Mosconi win all three sets. On the record alone, Mosconi has the strongest claim to be the greatest pool player of all time, and still he never quite won the argument.

Harold Worst, the Three-Cushion Crossover

Worst is the strongest case here for the all-rounder. At 24, he won the 1954 world three-cushion title in Argentina, the youngest player ever to take it, before crossing into pocket billiards, where the money was. At the 1965 Johnston City tournament in Illinois, built to bring America’s road players and gamblers into one room, he won the nine-ball, straight pool and all-around titles in the same week. Lymphoma killed him at 37 the following year, and the Hall of Fame inducted him in 1970. Few careers in the sport did as much in so little time.

Luther Lassiter, the Norfolk Money Player

The Hall of Fame’s citation calls Lassiter, inducted in 1983, the finest nine-ball player ever in the view of many, and the reputation began in the poolrooms of wartime Norfolk, Virginia, where he was reported to be the city’s leading hustler, with one week said to have brought him $15,000. Those figures come from poolroom memory rather than any ledger. At a 1966 world title challenge, the story goes, he pretended to fall asleep in his chair while Cisero Murphy was on a long run; Murphy missed, and Lassiter ran out. He died in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, in 1988, living on a pension from a childhood friend. The Norfolk money had gone long before.

Minnesota Fats, the Hustler Without a Title

Rudolf Wanderone, inducted in 1984, is the only player here honored for meritorious service rather than for play, and the Hall of Fame’s own entry notes that he never won a designated world championship. What he won was a name. The Hustler gave Jackie Gleason a character called Minnesota Fats, and Wanderone promptly dropped his old billing as New York Fats and said the role was based on him, a claim the novelist Walter Tevis denied for the rest of his life. The film, which only just misses a place among the best gambling movies ever made, did more for his income than any match he played.

In 1980 he claimed he had never lost a real money game, and his biographer, R.A. Dyer, wrote that pool hustlers are by nature liars. Among famous pool players, Fats is the one whose fame and record point in opposite directions.

A man is playing pool while other men are watching him.

Mike Sigel, Mr. Finals

Sigel built the cleanest tournament record of his generation. By 1986, he had won 63 of the 68 finals he reached, hence the nickname Mr. Finals, on his way to three world straight pool titles, three U.S. Open nine-ball titles and a Hall of Fame place in 1989. His first-place checks rose from $25,000 in 1979 to $40,000 in 1986, nearly three times the purse of the Mosconi and Fats television match. In a sport that romanticized the hustle, Sigel made his name on the published schedule.

Cisero Murphy, the Brooklyn Breakthrough

Murphy’s obstacle was never the table. He won the New York City championship as a teenager and was kept out of world and national events until pickets outside the Commodore Hotel in Manhattan protested his exclusion in 1964. Invited to the 1965 world tournament in Burbank, California, he won it on his first attempt. The Hall of Fame, which inducted him in 1995, describes him as the first and only African American to win a world or U.S. national billiard title. Ebony reported that his championship year earned him about $8,000, a thin living for a world champion. He paid for every barrier with years he could have spent winning.

Efren Reyes, the Magician from Manila

Reyes moved to Manila at five to live with an uncle who owned a pool hall, where he slept on the tables and played standing on soft drink crates, and he won his first game for money at nine. That apprenticeship was the Philippine game in miniature, with halls running on wagers and side bets, and by the late 1970s the American writer John Grissim reported that Reyes could give top U.S. professionals the eight and the break in Manila. Arriving in the United States in the mid-1980s, he entered a nine-ball open at Red’s in Houston as “Cesar Morales”, because American players knew his name but not his face. Billiards Digest records that he won $10,500 while his Filipino backers bet on him.

The titles followed, including the 1994 U.S. Open nine-ball, the 1999 world nine-ball championship and the 2004 world eight-ball title, which made him the first man to win WPA world titles in two disciplines, and he entered the Hall of Fame in 2003. Reyes has said he once made $80,000 in a single week of American money games, a figure that rests on his word alone. The Hong Kong match against Strickland, promoted as the Color of Money challenge, remains the strongest single argument for him as the greatest pool player of all time, a gambler’s format won with a champion’s nerve.

Earl Strickland, the Pearl and the Million

Strickland owns the strongest nine-ball record of any American of his era, with WPA world titles in 1990, 1991 and 2002 and a record five U.S. Open nine-ball championships, and he joined the Hall of Fame in 2006. His most famous run produced no title. At the first PCA tournament in 1996, the promoters offered $1 million to anyone who could break and run ten racks, and Strickland ran eleven. The insurer refused to pay, the lawsuits ran about two and a half years, and legal costs cut into the million. A million dollars won in a few minutes took longer to collect than most careers take to peak.

Allison Fisher, Snooker’s Champion Turned Pool’s

Fisher came to American pool with a run of women’s world snooker titles behind her, the first in 1985, and moved to the United States in 1995 to play the women’s professional tour full time. Billiards Digest’s 2009 profile, “Her Majesty”, called her the greatest woman player ever, and the record backs it, with world nine-ball titles in 1996 and 2001 among others and five consecutive Player of the Year awards. She was elected to the Hall of Fame in 2009 with 75 percent of the ballots. Fisher’s place among the top pool players of all time needs no qualifier.

Francisco Bustamante, Django from Tarlac

Bustamante grew up the youngest of eight in Tarlac and learned the game racking balls in his sister’s pool hall, practising alone after closing, and the nickname Django came from his resemblance, cigarette included, to the hero of the 1966 Western. He lost the 2002 world final to Strickland 17 to 15 after leading 15 to 13, at an event where he learned by telephone that his infant daughter had died, and Reyes was among those who persuaded him to keep playing. In 2010, at 46, he finally became world nine-ball champion and entered the Hall of Fame the same year. Few champions have needed so much patience for one title.

Jeanette Lee, the Black Widow

Lee’s nickname came from Gabe Vigorito, owner of the Howard Beach Billiard Club, who financed her early tournament entries and said she ate opponents alive while dressed in black. She was ranked the No. 1 woman in the world during the 1990s and took gold for the United States at the 2001 World Games in Japan. The Hall of Fame, which inducted her in 2013, calls her the most recognizable contemporary pool player in the world, a judgment about television as much as titles, and an accurate one. Lee sold the game to an audience that had never set foot in a poolroom.

Shane Van Boening, the South Dakota Kid

Van Boening entered the Hall of Fame in 2024, named on 96 percent of ballots in his first year of eligibility, against the 75 percent that elected Fisher fifteen years earlier. His five U.S. Open nine-ball titles match Strickland’s record, and he added the world nine-ball title in 2022 and the world eight-ball title in 2023. The Derby City Classic, held each January near Louisville, runs buy-back events in bank pool, one-pocket and nine-ball, and Van Boening has won its Master of the Table title three times. His pay-per-view races to 120 racks of ten-ball against Fedor Gorst are the nearest thing the modern game has to the Hong Kong match. Nobody of his generation has a stronger entry in both ledgers.

Fedor Gorst, the Champion in Waiting

Gorst, born in Moscow in 2000 and now based in the United States, is the one name here without a Hall of Fame plaque, and his results already argue for one. He won the WPA world nine-ball title in 2019 and 2024, then took the 2024 U.S. Open by beating Van Boening 13 to 10. At the Derby City Classic, he has won the overall title three times, with bank pool and one-pocket wins along the way, games that reward the patience of money play over break-and-run speed. Gorst’s record is the one the next decade will be measured against.

Who Is Considered the Greatest Pool Player of All Time?

Most players narrow the answer to two names, with a third that depends on the game. Mosconi’s case rests on the record, with fifteen world titles and an exhibition run of 526 balls in Springfield, Ohio, in 1954, sworn to by more than 35 witnesses. The case for Reyes rests on range and on both ledgers at once, which is why players’ forums so often treat him as the default answer to the question of the best pool player ever.

Strickland is the nine-ball choice for many Americans, and anyone asking who is the best pool player in the world today, rather than the greatest pool player of all time, will find the strongest recent record belongs to Gorst. The hustlers fared worse. Lassiter’s Norfolk winnings ended in a pension from a friend, Fats’ claims collapsed against his record, and Archie Karas, who hustled pool in Los Angeles before taking his bankroll into Las Vegas casinos, lost nearly all of the fortune he built there. Pool has always paid its champions in two currencies, and only the titles kept their value.